top of page
GSV Logo 2026.png

Can the US fix its nursing shortage?

Thomas Thurston
4 days ago
14 min read

My team has been analyzing a lot of healthcare value chains lately, from wound care in Australia, to at-home care in the US, to women’s reproductive health in Kenya and beyond. In one analysis after another, we can’t help but notice how frequently nursing shortages arise as a critical bottleneck.


It probably doesn’t surprise you to hear that the world needs more qualified nurses. Without nurses on the front lines, just about every step in the healthcare system can come to a grinding halt. The nursing shortage is bad, especially in the US, and aging boomers are adding to the pressure. After seeing this bottleneck turn up again and again, we got curious.[i]


Why is there a nursing shortage? What are the bottlenecks within the bottleneck? What, if anything, might help?


The good news is, people still want to be nurses. Applications to entry-level bachelor’s nursing programs rose 17.1% in 2025, according to the American Association of Colleges of Nursing.[ii] So... why isn't supply keeping up with demand?


To try and get to the bottom of this, we fired up our servers and started analyzing “nursing workforce capacity” as a value chain in its own right. With aging boomers in mind, we narrowed our focus to nursing care for patients 65 and older in the US.


We wanted to take the system apart, map its dependencies and identify its critical bottlenecks. Which constraints were the most persistent? Which had the greatest influence on the rest of the system? If we could pinpoint those bottlenecks, we might get a better sense of where a few focused efforts could have the deepest and broadest impact.


The analysis covered nurse education, specialized training, recruitment, retention, reentry and mentorship. We also looked at workforce financing, deploying nurses where needs are greatest, expanding care team responsibilities and technologies that help nurses deliver more care. In total, we analyzed 1,680 factors, including 1,000 granular technologies integral to these interrelated systems and how they operate day-to-day.


In this massive system, we found only 55 significant bottlenecks. That was the first surprise. Given the scope of the problem, I’d expected more. Of those 55, only nine were both critical (show stoppers versus nice-to-haves) and long-term, meaning we expected them to persist for three years or longer. In other words, nine bottlenecks were disproportionately holding back systemic progress in the nursing crisis.


Within the nine, things got even more interesting.


Five of the nine pointed to the same underlying problem.


What was it?


Nurse preceptors.


What's a "Nurse Preceptor?"


I’ll admit, I had no idea what a nurse preceptor was. Had to Google it.


Evidently, a nurse preceptor is an experienced nurse who teaches and mentors nursing students or new nurses, helping them build clinical skills and meet training requirements. It’s that simple.


Well, not really. The more I learned about nurse preceptors, the more I started to worry.


Before becoming licensed, aspiring registered nurses need lots of hands-on training. In California, for example, they need at least 500 hours of direct patient care as part of their nursing education. That includes at least 30 supervised clinical hours in each of five areas: geriatrics, medical-surgical nursing, mental health/psychiatric nursing, obstetrics and pediatrics.[iii]


Those aren’t all individual preceptor hours. Some training happens in groups with clinical instructors. For advanced practice students, doctors, PAs and other health professionals can also help with parts of the training. That said, working with a nurse preceptor is a huge part of the process.[iv] Altogether, it can take substantial time and effort from multiple preceptors and clinical instructors across several rotations just to produce a single new nurse.


This all sounds fine. After all, it’s reassuring to hear that nurses receive rigorous hands-on training. What’s the problem?


Where do Nursing Students Find Preceptors?


For nursing students, some schools and nursing degrees provide preceptors, but others don't. That's the problem.


For example, George Washington University arranges clinical placements for its undergraduate nursing students, who train in groups with clinical faculty and complete an individual preceptorship toward the end of the program. Meanwhile, at the exact same school, most grad students have to find and secure their own clinical sites and preceptors. The school's advice? Network with practitioners, alumni, and other students (gee, thanks). The training is required, but finding a preceptor to finish that training is something the student has to figure out themself.[v]


We didn’t find a reliable national count of how many nurse practitioner programs guarantee preceptors, but I was surprised by how many programs explicitly require students to find their own. A shortage of preceptors can also mean that schools turn away qualified applicants even before they enroll.


There are also staffing agencies and online platforms like NPHub to help nurse practitioner students find preceptors. That’s a good thing, but for students whose schools don’t arrange placements, it's like a job search. Some services even charge students directly for matching them with preceptors, with fees that can run into thousands of dollars for a single clinical rotation. That’s another expense on top of tuition. Former nurses returning to practice after a long break may also have to find their own clinical placements, so the issue affects both new and experienced nurses alike.


For a lot of these students and returning nurses in need of preceptors, the message is clear.


You’re on your own.[vi]


The good news is that it isn’t impossible to find a preceptor. The bad news is that students are looking for help from a workforce that’s already stretched thin. An unusually high number of nurses left the profession during COVID, and nurses have continued to leave because of stress, burnout and retirement. It’s all happening just as boomers hit their 80s, so with each departing nurse you lose both that nurse (themselves) and also a potential preceptor for new nurses entering the profession. It's a double-whammy. [vii]


That’s bad, but we haven’t gotten to the really bad part yet.


Why would an experienced nurse want to be a preceptor?


Often, they don't. Worse yet, even if they want to be a preceptor, it can be impractical.


Here’s why.


Today, in the US, there are active disincentives for experienced nurses to train and mentor new nurses. It isn't a selfish plot to help keep the skilled workforce small. It's because experienced nurses don't always get more time or money for training others, and doing so can hurt their daily performance metrics. For example, in a 2024 Texas survey, 130 of 193 clinical sites reported no compensation for the extra precepting work. That’s about two thirds of responding sites in one state.[viii]


Don't get me wrong, there are certainly nurses who want to be preceptors. For example, since nurses were themselves mentored at some point, they can view preceptorship as an important way to give back. Some enjoy teaching. Others find value in developing future colleagues and mentoring the next generation.[ix]


That’s honorable, but it’s also fragile.


Nurses can face long hours, demanding workloads, burnout and stress. They often get little or no instruction on how to train others. They can face bullying and abuse from patients, doctors and other nurses. The work is high-stakes, detailed, often ambiguous and unpredictable. Sometimes even the tiniest oversights can have catastrophic consequences. It’s a lot to manage before you add a trainee.[x]


Imagine an experienced nurse in that environment. They’re working in a system that tracks productivity, error rates, timeliness, fall prevention, catheter events, new pressure injuries, central line-associated infections, medication administration, RN hours per patient day and patient communication. Patient experience is measured too. Now try getting a good “experience” review from a patient who is spitting at you during a drug-induced psychosis.[xi]


While all this is happening, ask that nurse to simultaneously divert their time and attention to training one or more nursing students. They need to let those students participate in delivering care wherever possible, instead of just observing. Then give the preceptor no additional time or money for their troubles. Keep every daily responsibility unchanged. Hold them responsible for providing safe supervision, too, potentially punishing them for any of their trainee's mistakes.[xii]


It’s a vicious cycle. There’s a nursing shortage, so existing nurses are overloaded and stretched thin. That leaves them little time and very real disincentives to train new nurses. As a result, there are fewer new nurses, which makes the shortage worse.


Repeat.


That’s the bottleneck.


What would it take to fix this? Can we break the vicious cycle?


Smart people have spent a lot of time and money working on this, with mixed results. Some efforts pay nurses to teach. Others make room for teaching within the working day. Still others change how students get their clinical training.


Those are different approaches. Paying a nurse a bonus doesn’t necessarily give them more time to teach. Giving them teaching time doesn’t necessarily cover the patients they would otherwise care for.


It also matters who’s being trained. Some programs help students become registered nurses. Others help nurses pursue advanced practice degrees. Success in one doesn’t automatically tell us what will work in the other.


Start with paying people to teach.


Colorado offers a tax credit for qualifying preceptors in rural and frontier primary care. An audit of the older $1,000-a-year credit found limited uptake: 83 taxpayers claimed it in 2021, below the then-cap of 200. From 2025, the state increased the benefit to $2,000 per qualifying preceptorship, up to three per year, with a limit of 300 preceptors statewide across eligible professions. The older audit doesn’t tell us how well that expanded benefit worked out.[xiii]


Michigan tried stipends of $500–$1,500 for nurse practitioner preceptors. Its pilot included 42 existing preceptors and 18 new ones. That’s encouraging, but without a comparison group, the report couldn’t establish how many the payments actually added. The authors also recommended more support for preceptors, earlier recruitment and simpler administration.[xiv]


These efforts show why participation alone isn’t enough to judge success. People may claim a credit or accept a stipend for teaching they would have done anyway. The question is whether the payment makes more training possible.


Other programs have tried to make teaching part of the everyday job.


The VA Nursing Academy funded faculty roles for experienced nurses. But an evaluation of 15 partnerships found hiring delays and trouble replacing nurses who were released from patient care to teach. Paying for a teaching role didn’t make the staffing problem disappear.[xv]


North Carolina’s Clinical Instructor Partnership Program has nurses split their time between clinical work and teaching, with schools and employers sharing costs. By fall 2024, the program reported that 75 trained nurses had taught nearly 200 students. Schools also reported room to enroll more. Those are promising signs, although the report didn’t establish how many additional graduates the program produced.[xvi]


Dedicated Education Units take another approach: staff nurses teach students with faculty support. In one evaluation, some nurses received temporary relief from patient assignments early in rotations. The school reported increased clinical capacity and doubled enrollment during the project. That’s encouraging local growth, but the evaluation couldn’t isolate how much came from the model itself.[xvii] Still, examples like this make me optimistic.


One of the stronger findings came from Medicare’s Graduate Nurse Education demonstration. It paid five hospital networks to expand clinical training for advanced practice registered nurses. An evaluation using a comparison group estimated around 35 additional graduates per participating school per year.[xx]


That’s a meaningful result, but the program included several kinds of support, including payments to clinical sites and some preceptor bonuses. Evaluators couldn’t isolate which pieces drove the gains, and the results concern advanced practice nurses, rather than students becoming registered nurses for the first time.


It's also worth mentioning that simulation can help (like practicing on a high-tech medical dummy or using virtual reality to walk through patient care scenarios).


Simulation can reduce some of the demand for traditional clinical placements. For example, a randomized study found no significant differences in major learning outcomes or early practice ratings when high-quality simulation replaced up to half of traditional clinical hours. That’s useful. It suggests some training can happen outside the usual hospital floor, provided schools have trained faculty and adequate resources. The study didn’t test whether doing so ultimately produced more nurses, but it can help lighten the load.[xviii]


That said, even simulation has staffing problems of its own. In a 2024 survey of 11 North Dakota nursing schools, 91% reported insufficient funding. Sixty-four percent reported shortages of task trainers, supplies or standardized patient models. Eighty-two percent said they needed faculty training, and the same share said workloads didn’t include additional time for simulation.[xix]


Even when technology can take pressure off clinical placements, people still need time and resources to use it.


Looking at all these efforts, here’s what I took away.


Some approaches have helped. Medicare’s demonstration produced an estimated increase in advanced practice nursing graduates. The simulation study showed that schools could replace some traditional clinical hours without significant differences in the major outcomes measured. Local teaching partnerships reported more teaching activity or room for more students.[xxi]


The disappointments were more specific. Colorado’s older tax credit had low uptake. Michigan’s pilot couldn’t establish how many preceptors its stipends added. A Dutch placement subsidy gave organizations little incentive to add placements when supervisors were already scarce. None of that establishes that paying for teaching can’t work. It shows that the details matter.[xxii]


We have to make teaching possible within the working day. A bonus may help, but it doesn’t cover a nurse’s patients while they teach. A funded teaching role may help, but someone still has to fill the shift they leave behind. Simulation may help, but it needs trained people, equipment and time.


What still deserves a clearer test is the combination: extra pay, protected teaching time, funded patient-care coverage and preparation to teach. Some of those pieces have already been tried. A useful next step would compare different combinations and track additional graduates, patient care and full costs over time.


That's what we learned.


What’s the highest priority bottleneck behind the nursing shortage?


Nurses themselves. Namely, giving experienced nurses the time, money and training to teach and mentor the next generation. Not a technology. Not infrastructure. Not even a clinical breakthrough. Just people in a critical role that we need to give a little more time and care to, the way they care for us.






End Notes


[i] WHO, “Nursing” fact sheet; HRSA, Nurse Workforce Projections 2023–2038, December 2025; US Census Bureau, The Older Population 2020, May 2023. These support shortages and demographic pressure, not uninterrupted decline in every nursing occupation or location. WHO fact sheet. HRSA projections. Census report.

[ii] AACN, “Schools of Nursing See Enrollment Increases Across Most Program Levels, Signaling Strong Interest in Nursing Careers,” May 7, 2026, “Applications Received and Turned Away.” Responses from 998 schools, an 89.5% response rate. These are entry-level BSN applications, not unique applicants or all nursing pathways. AACN survey release.

[iii] California BRN, “Prelicensure Distance Education Institutional and Programmatic Information,” curriculum table, referencing 16 CCR 1426 and Business and Professions Code 2786(a)(2). This guidance does not require every clinical hour to be an individual preceptorship. BRN published requirements.

[iv] NACNEP, Mitigating Nursing Workforce Challenges by Optimizing Learning Environments, 19th report, January 2024, pp. 14–15. The report distinguishes faculty-led clinical groups from individualized preceptorships and discusses preceptors supporting both students and nurses transitioning into practice. Required clinical hours should not be equated with individual preceptor hours. NACNEP report. AACN, Clinical Preceptor Guide, identifies physicians, physician assistants and other health professionals as partners in APRN clinical education and experienced APRNs as critical to preparation for the APRN role. AACN preceptor guide.

[v] George Washington University School of Nursing, “Clinical Rotations,” undergraduate and graduate program sections, accessed November 14, 2026. Program staff arrange undergraduate placements, including faculty-led small groups and a later individual preceptorship. Most graduate students identify and secure their own sites and preceptors; the placement team assists with approval and agreements. Adult-Gerontology Acute Care Nurse Practitioner options are excepted. For limits on entry-level admissions, NACNEP, 19th report, pp. 10–11, and Texas Center for Nursing Workforce Studies, 2024 Texas Clinical Training Needs, p. 1: 17 of 71 responding prelicensure programs reported rejecting qualified applicants because of insufficient clinical placements. These findings do not establish that every rejected applicant was unable to enroll elsewhere or that all schools use the same placement model. GW policy and exception. NACNEP report. Texas prelicensure survey.

[vi] NPHub, “Pricing” and “How It Works,” accessed November 14, 2026. The company charges students for rotation matching and coordination, with rates starting at $12.75 per clinical hour plus applicable fees. These are provider-reported prices, not evidence of effectiveness or a national average. South Dakota State University, “RN and LPN Independent Study Refresher Courses,” enrollment steps and clinical component: participants must arrange a clinical site commitment before enrollment; the university subsequently establishes an affiliation agreement. This is a program example, not a claim that all returning nurses receive no placement assistance. NPHub pricing. NPHub process. SDSU refresher requirements.

[vii] HRSA, 2022 National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses Snapshot, March 2024, reports pandemic-related departures. NCSBN’s 2024 workforce findings report continued departures alongside recovery. Departures do not imply a net decline in the total workforce, and neither source establishes a daily decline in the number of available preceptors. HRSA snapshot. NCSBN recovery and departures.

[viii] NACNEP, 19th report, January 2024, pp. 15–16, on compensation and workload relief. Texas Center for Nursing Workforce Studies, 2024 Texas Clinical Training Needs, January 2025, p. 2 and Table 10: 130 of 193 responding sites (67.4%) reported no compensation for additional precepting work. Texas is not a national estimate. NACNEP report. Texas survey.

[ix] Michigan State University College of Nursing and MDHHS, Clinical Preceptor Incentive Pilot Program Report, pp. 8–10, motivation survey and comments. Teaching, professional obligation and personal fulfillment were reported motivations, not universal findings. Michigan report.

[x] HRSA’s RN survey snapshot documents burnout; NACNEP’s 19th report, p. 15, discusses limited preparation for precepting. ANA, Position Statement on Workplace Violence, 2025, addresses violence and bullying from patients and colleagues. The assessment of distraction is the author’s. HRSA survey. ANA workplace violence position.

[xi] AHRQ, Patient Safety and Quality, chapter 25, “Nurse Staffing and Patient Care Quality and Safety”; CMS, “HCAHPS: Patients’ Perspectives of Care Survey.” These describe nursing-sensitive and hospital-level measures, not a universal individual scorecard. The amputation scenario is hypothetical, not a reported patient case. AHRQ indicators. CMS patient experience.

[xii] NACNEP, 19th report, pp. 15–16, on workload expectations. ANA Code of Ethics for Nurses, 2025, Provision 4.4, on oversight of student nurses and the institutional support educators and preceptors should receive. Responsibility for supervision does not imply automatic legal liability for every student mistake. NACNEP report. ANA student supervision.

[xiii] Colorado Office of the State Auditor, Rural & Frontier Healthcare Preceptor Credit, 2023-TE11, August 2023, printed pp. 3–9. The audit evaluated the older $1,000 annual benefit: 92 taxpayers were approved and 83 claimed it in 2021, below the then-cap of 200. RN eligibility and the 300-preceptor cap began in 2022. The auditor suggested credits for multiple preceptorships. Colorado Department of Revenue, December 2025 Updates, confirms that from tax year 2025 the credit increased to $2,000 per qualifying preceptorship, up to three ($6,000/year). Current Form DR 0366 instructions, pp. 1–2, retain a 300-preceptor annual cap across eligible professions and require uncompensated preceptorships lasting at least four working weeks or 20 business days. The cap limits who can claim the credit, not how many people may serve as preceptors. The 2023 audit does not evaluate the expanded benefit or establish that the cap constrained participation. 2023 audit. 2025 benefit change. Current credit and cap.

[xiv] Michigan State University College of Nursing and MDHHS, Clinical Preceptor Incentive Pilot Program Report, pp. 6–10 and 12–14. Participation counts are reported outputs. Proposed strategies draw on pilot experience and cited literature; the pilot did not experimentally test those recommendations. Original pilot report.

[xv] Dobalian et al., The critical elements of effective academic-practice partnerships: a framework derived from the Department of Veterans Affairs Nursing Academy, BMC Nursing 13:36, December 20, 2014. Qualitative launch-year evaluation: 142 interviews and 23 focus groups. See faculty recruitment, backfill and long-term commitment findings. Original qualitative evaluation.

[xvi] NC Center on the Workforce for Health, Clinical Instructor Partnership Program, How it works and Results, accessed November 13, 2026. These are operator-reported activity and school-survey findings, not an independent controlled evaluation. Nearly all surveyed schools reported the ability to enroll more students; the page does not report a survey denominator. Program structure and reported results.

[xvii] Moscato et al., Dedicated education unit: An innovative clinical partner education model, Nursing Outlook 55:31–37, 2007, especially pp. 35–36. Formative evaluation across six units in three hospitals. Reduced assignments/resource nurses were temporary adjustments early in rotations. Reported enrollment growth is not a controlled estimate of the model’s effect. Original DEU evaluation.

[xviii] Hayden et al., The NCSBN National Simulation Study, Journal of Nursing Regulation 5(2 supplement), July 2014, pp. S3 and S38. Ten programs, 847 students randomized and 666 completing the study. Comparable measured outcomes among study groups do not establish identical outcomes in every circumstance. The conclusion specifies faculty preparation, adequate faculty numbers, expert debriefing and equipment/supplies. Original randomized study.

[xix] Zwilling et al., Simulation Use in North Dakota Nursing Programs, North Dakota Nursing Research Collaborative, March 2024, Table 3. Eleven of fourteen schools participated. The 64% measure groups task trainers, supplies and standardized patient models; it does not separately count manikins or human trainers. A descriptive state survey, not an evaluation of simulation effectiveness. Original survey and Table 3.

[xx] Hesgrove et al., The Graduate Nurse Education Demonstration Project: Final Evaluation Report, CMS, August 2019, pp. 8, 37–38, 52–53 and 85–86. Quasi-experimental weighted difference-in-differences estimate, not random assignment. Payments included clinical-site compensation and some preceptor bonuses. The evaluation could not isolate individual program mechanisms; participating schools differed from the national population. Original CMS final evaluation.

[xxi] Synthesis of reported findings, with evidence levels kept separate: CMS final GNE evaluation, pp. 52–53 and 85–86; Hayden et al., 2014, pp. S3 and S38; Moscato et al., 2007, pp. 35–36; NC Center on the Workforce for Health, CIP Results. GNE is quasi-experimental, simulation randomized, DEU observational and NC activity/capacity operator-reported. These sources do not establish a single best design for prelicensure nursing. GNE. Simulation trial. DEU evaluation. North Carolina program report.

[xxii] Colorado 2023-TE11, pp. 5–9, limited uptake of the older $1,000 annual benefit, before the 2025 increase; Netherlands Court of Audit, May 17, 2023 Stagefonds findings, limited incentive effect and available supervisors as the main constraint; Michigan pilot report, pp. 6–10, participation without a comparison group. These are distinct findings about particular designs, not a controlled comparison of all payment approaches. Colorado audit. Dutch audit findings. Michigan pilot. Colorado’s subsequent benefit increase and current 300-preceptor cap are documented separately by the Department of Revenue. 2025 benefit change. Current credit and cap.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page